A Disingenuous Flair of Rhetorical Nonsense
By Bill Jamieson | October 27th, 2011 | Category: The Front Page | 1 Comment »In a disingenuous flair of rhetorical nonsense, the Chair of the House Budget Committee told the Heritage Foundation that President Barack Obama was “sowing unrest and class resentment… (and) preying on the emotions of fear…”
In his October 25 speech before the ultra-right organization Paul Ryan said that Obama is making “America weaker, not stronger” and he accused the President of “exacerbating class warfare.”
This is from the man who authored a budget that gave tax cuts to the ultra-wealthy and slashed programs that serve the poor, elderly and disabled. This audacious claim was made by a man whose party has relentlessly attacked the President, labeling him an illegal alien, a Muslim, a socialist.
In fact, Ryan and his colleagues are the culprits who have stoked unrest and class resentment through their tax proposals and social agenda, and they regularly impugn the motives of the President, Democrats and all of us who fight for a progressive agenda. When we dare to invite them to think rationally, they loudly accuse us of “sowing social unrest.”
It is Ryan who represents a Party that preyed “on the emotions of fear” that led America into what I believe was a senseless war in Iraq, and they used fear to gain public acceptance for dismantling individual freedoms through the Patriot Act.
Fanning fear has been a primary Republican campaign tactic in elections since 2004 when President Bush ran for reelection by stoking the memory of 9/11 and suggesting that only he could save us from another terrorist attack.
This 2004 fear of terrorism has been updated to fear of “the other”: fear of undocumented aliens taking “our jobs”, fear of gay and lesbian people perverting God’s marital mandates, fear that regulations on industry— environmental, financial and safety— are the cause of any recession.
And most of all, they tell us to fear President Obama because he will destroy “our America” by advocating Sharia law, turning the country to socialism, and selling out the country to a one-world government.
The ultimate irony is that it is Republicans who are the one-worldists: a world focused solely on profiteering of the few undergirded by cheap labor from the many— and ruled, of course, by their exceptional America.
The Republican leaders are betting that by stoking fear of the President in the minds of the voters people will forget that the Republican-led House refuses to introduce almost any Obama proposal for a vote.
They are betting that most people will dismiss as irrelevant the Senate Republicans’ filibuster of the President’s initiatives on jobs, budget and taxes, key appointments, and environmental sustainability, thus preventing them from being voted on. And Republicans are betting that the people will believe them when they label him a “do-nothing” President.
When President Obama fights back, when he tells the truth about the unprincipled behavior of Republicans, he is accused (in Ryan’s words) of “impugning the motives of Republicans, setting up straw men and scapegoats, and engaging in intellectually lazy arguments…”
Congressman Ryan must have been looking in a mirror when he wrote that speech.
Facebook
Twitter
email
Add to favorites
Digg
StumbleUpon
Thank you, Bill, for this trenchant report on the current trends of fear-bating in the Republican party—a party that proudly claims most of its participants are Christian. One thing I find shocking is how many of these so-called Christians are content to tell bold-faced lies and foment hate in the name of maintaining luxuries for themselves and the very few already privileged.
As a professor of world religions and multi-faith minister, I am stunned into silence (almost, thank God!).
If Jesus lived in the 21st century, I’m wondering how quick he would accuse as “cheats and thieves” the poorest among us, foster children, the sick, the widowed, the imprisoned, the social outcasts, the unfamiliar stranger? I wonder if Jesus could keep his hands from flipping over the tables of those (mostly) men who’ll do anything—even break the laws of the land—to preserve present and future personal profit over a viable future for all living beings.
And even if Obama were a Muslim instead of an unabashedly proud Christian, would not Jesus consider him family?
Obama hate-mongerers truly puzzle me. Where’s the Christian love in all of this? Where’s the commitment to caring for one another? Where’s the covenant to love our neighbors as ourselves…no matter how unfamiliar they are to us?
Again, thanks for inviting all of us to wake up!
P.S. I forgot to share with you and my readers a funny thing my nephew wondered aloud yesterday. He asked, “If you have a right wing, don’t you need a left wing to fly?” I smiled and nodded while thinking to myself: “These right-wingers are indeed missing a wing but it’s their lies that cannot fly.”
I’m hoping that more of us will resist believing the lies of this flagrantly dishonest wing of the party. More will be revealed come next November.